|
How this guide was prepared. Last updated October 2026. It draws on Brandmovers' experience designing, migrating and relaunching loyalty programs. It also draws on company announcements from Allegiant, Sun Country and Marriott, the US Department of Transportation's merger conditions for Alaska and Hawaiian Airlines, and accounting and privacy rules, each checked at its source. |
Loyalty program consolidation is the process of combining two companies' loyalty programs after a merger or acquisition: choosing which program survives, converting points balances and tier status, moving member data, and telling members what changes for them.
Deal activity keeps this problem current. Writing on the Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance in December 2025, Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz said US M&A volume was on pace to reach about $2.3 trillion in 2025, up 49% from 2024. When the target runs a loyalty program, whether for consumers or channel partners, the program comes with it: members, points balances, tier status and promises that the acquirer now owns. Allegiant's acquisition of Sun Country Airlines is a current example. Announced on January 11, 2026, the deal promised "expanded frequent flyer and membership benefits, combining the best of both airlines' programs," adding Sun Country's more than 2 million loyalty members to Allegiant's 21 million. When it closed on May 13, 2026, Allegiant said Allegiant Allways Rewards and Sun Country Rewards would remain separate in the near term, with members' points, benefits and account status keeping their current value. This guide covers how to choose a consolidation model, set a fair conversion rate, meet the rules that apply, communicate with members, migrate the data, and measure whether the consolidation worked.
|
Loyalty consolidation is easy to underplan because a program can look like a marketing asset to sort out after close, when it is also a financial obligation and a set of promises to the target's best customers.
A loyalty program can fall outside the first wave of integration planning, yet an outstanding points balance is a liability the acquirer takes on at close, and a member's tier status reflects spending the member did because the program promised specific benefits. Treating either as a detail the new owner can change at will risks losing the customers the deal was meant to acquire.
The costly surprises tend to surface late:
Each of these changes the model, the timeline and what can honestly be said to members at announcement. Found in due diligence, they shape the plan. Found months after close, they force rushed decisions and messages that have to be corrected later.
The three models are a full merger into one surviving program, a portfolio model in which both programs survive with shared earning and redemption, and a phased migration in which both run in parallel until members move to the destination program.
In a full merger, one program survives and members of the other move into it at a set conversion rate and tier equivalency, after which the retired program closes. Marriott is a widely cited example. Marriott announced in April 2018 that Marriott Rewards, The Ritz-Carlton Rewards and Starwood Preferred Guest would move to one set of benefits and a single points currency in August 2018, when "SPG members will see their points balance triple," and that members could combine their accounts. The Marriott Bonvoy name replaced all three in February 2019. Allegiant's stated plan to combine "the best of both airlines' programs" points toward the same model.
A full merger is the simplest to run and removes the cost of two platforms, two catalogs and two communication streams. It fits when one program is clearly stronger in design, value and technology. The risk is that members attached to the retired program's particular features see the move as a downgrade even when the surviving program is comparable overall, so each member needs to see how their own balance and status carry across.
In a portfolio model, both programs keep their identities while members earn and redeem across both brands through a shared layer. It works like a coalition currency run inside one company. The model fits when the brands serve different customers and members are loyal to the brand rather than the parent company. It costs more to run, with two platforms, two catalogs and two tier structures plus the integration between them, and if the brands are likely to merge later, it builds up work that will have to be undone.
In a phased migration, both programs run in parallel for a set period while the destination program is prepared and members move in groups, after which the acquired program closes. It suits large member bases, complex platforms and members who are strongly attached to the acquired program. Its value depends on a specific, published timeline. A member told the conversion rate, the tier match and the date can plan around them. A member told only that the programs will "eventually" combine has reason to redeem everything now, which can create a redemption surge the financial model did not expect.
|
Factor |
Favors full merger |
Favors portfolio model |
Favors phased migration |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Brand strategy |
One brand will survive long-term |
Both brands stay distinct and serve different customers |
The destination brand is clear, but timing is constrained by technology, communication or regulatory review |
|
Program quality |
One program is clearly stronger; moving is an upgrade |
Each program has strengths different customers value |
The destination program needs improvements before it can receive members at full value |
|
Technology |
The surviving platform is ready for the combined base; the other is ending |
Both platforms are viable long-term, and cross-brand earning is feasible |
The surviving platform needs work, and a phased timeline lets readiness come first |
|
Member overlap |
Low; most members belong to one program |
High; members are active in both |
Moderate; cohorts let identity matching proceed carefully |
|
Liability accounting |
The combined liability can be measured and provided for in one program |
Liabilities stay on separate books; cross-brand redemption adds intercompany accounting |
Liabilities move as each cohort migrates |
|
Communication risk |
Low if the move is clearly an upgrade |
Low if it only adds options; higher if members lose brand-specific benefits |
Moderate; a long period of uncertainty makes timeline and rate details critical |
If only one company runs a program, the task is enrollment rather than conversion: invite the other company's customers with a welcome offer and apply the same consent checks.
Each model fails when it is chosen for operational convenience rather than for what members of both programs value and what the combined business plans to become.
In each case, the cheaper option in year one can be the more expensive one once lost members and rework are counted.
Set the conversion rate by valuing each program's points at what members actually get for them when they redeem, then decide how much of a margin in members' favor the combined business will fund.
Start with the accounting. Points balances are obligations the acquirer takes on at close. Under US GAAP, ASU 2021-08 requires an acquirer to recognize and measure contract liabilities acquired in a business combination, such as deferred revenue for loyalty points, under ASC 606, as if it had entered into the original contracts itself; for public companies it applies to fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2022. How that applies to a specific program is a question for the acquirer's finance team and auditors, and it belongs in due diligence. The CFO guide to loyalty liability covers the underlying accounting.
Then value the currencies. For conversion design, the useful value of a point is what members typically get when they redeem it, based on the program's actual redemption mix. The advertised value per point and the cost of rewards to the company are different numbers. As an illustration, if members of Program A typically redeem points for about 1.0 cent each and members of Program B for about 0.8 cents, one Program B point is worth about 0.8 Program A points. Whether to convert at exactly that rate, round in members' favor, or add a migration bonus is a commercial decision, but it should start from correctly valued currencies. Because that value is an average, test the rate by member segment, especially heavy redeemers of the retired program's best-value rewards, and fund a floor or bonus for any group the average leaves worse off.
Test the rate against the "worse off" question. Members, and in aviation regulators, will judge a conversion on whether anyone loses value. When the Department of Transportation set conditions for the Alaska Airlines and Hawaiian Airlines merger on September 17, 2024, it required that miles earned before conversion not expire, that every mile convert into the new program at a 1:1 ratio, that the combined airline not devalue HawaiianMiles miles, and that members' status be matched or increased. That condition is specific to aviation, but it shows how a fair conversion is likely to be judged.
Plan for the redemption surge. Members who are unsure what their points will be worth have a reason to redeem them early. Announcing the conversion rate, the tier match and the date together reduces that uncertainty, and a rate or bonus that rewards keeping points gives members a reason to stay put. Model some early redemption anyway and fund it.
Loyalty consolidation is shaped by the programs' own terms, privacy law on transferred member data, and, in some industries, regulator conditions on the deal.
This is general information, not legal advice; confirm obligations with counsel before announcing changes to members.
Communicate early, specifically and honestly: tell members what is happening before it happens, show each member what changes for their own account, and say so directly when something changes in a way they will not like.
Brief customer service before each step so agents give the same answers members read. The loyalty communication guide covers the channel mix.
Loyalty data migration means moving five kinds of member data accurately into the surviving program: identity, points balances, tier status, transaction history and preferences, including consent records.
Identity matching is the hardest step when the programs overlap. The same person may have joined each program with a different email address or name spelling, so automated matching needs a manual review queue for uncertain matches, and combined balances should not be merged until a match is confirmed. Transaction history is a decision, not a default: keep enough to support tier qualification, personalization and dispute handling, and weigh it against the privacy principle of not keeping data longer than needed.
Cutover is the other big decision. A single cutover moves everyone on one date, which is simpler to explain but puts every member at risk if something fails. A cohort approach spreads the risk but means some members are on each system for a time, which complicates customer service. Cohorts suit very large or complex programs; a single cutover can suit smaller programs with clean data. Avoid peak trading periods either way.
A platform shutdown raises the same issues without a merger. When Aquatrols' previous loyalty vendor shut down, Brandmovers migrated and relaunched the program on BENGAGED™, Brandmovers' B2B channel incentives platform, and the relaunched program saw off-season sales increase as much as 23% at times (disclosed by Brandmovers). That was a replatform rather than an M&A consolidation, but it illustrates the value of treating migration as a relaunch. The platform migration guide, the replatforming checklist and the sunset, migration and relaunch playbook cover the technical steps in more detail.
Measure consolidation by whether the acquired program's members, especially its most valuable ones, stay active at the rate they did before the deal, not by whether the migration finished on time.
The loyalty KPI dashboard guide covers how to track these alongside standard program metrics.
Loyalty consolidation is not a clean-up task after the deal. It decides whether the target's best customers stay. The work starts in due diligence: audit both programs, value both currencies, check the terms and privacy notices, and choose a model that matches the combined company's brand plans. At announcement, give members specifics. During migration, protect balances and status and watch the members with the most at stake. Allegiant has promised Sun Country members the best of both programs; members will judge that promise by what happens to their points. If your company announced a deal tomorrow, could you tell every member of the target's program exactly what happens to their balance?
|
Planning a loyalty program consolidation? Brandmovers designs, migrates and relaunches loyalty programs and runs them on BLOYL™ and BENGAGED. Request a demo to talk it through with the Brandmovers team. |